Work in Progress Critique

Here is one of the photos that I have been working on for the constructed reality project. I have been playing around with the redness of the tomato. The original image of the tomato is much more muted and almost peachy pink looking which didn't look like a tomato, but when I saturated and played with the color balance, I was finding that the more saturated it was, the more superimposed it was looking. Obviously this cannot look even close to real, but there are differences with color.

I am debating between the low saturation and the blue photo. I am leaning toward the low saturation one, but still not sure. I feel like the gray tones work better together with the low saturation blue.